Super User III

You're not eligible to transfer a domain for a 60-day period after the following events:

• •Registering or transferring a domain name
• •Updating the registrant contact's organization
• •Updating the registrant contact's first or last name and an organization is not listed

You're not eligible to transfer a domain for a 10-day period after changing your domain from one GoDaddy account to another via the Account Change Process.

Could the domain be subject to one of the holds outlined above?  If not double check that the DomainsByProxy is canceled for that domain and it is unlocked and try the transfer again.

 

Here is the article on transferring a domain away just in case:

https://www.godaddy.com/help/transferring-domain-names-to-another-registrar-3560